All-season tires are meant to be driven year-round, so you’d expect them to last several seasons, especially on a commuter car that racks up miles. However, Michelin’s Primacy All-Season tires are not lasting as long as expected — not even close — causing a lot of backlash from drivers. “These tires lose tread quickly and will not last,” one customer wrote. “It only took 8,000 miles to consume over half of the tire’s tread. If your vehicle comes with these tires, do your best to get them changed.” 

This sentiment is shared by many customers on Michelin’s website, where the tires sit at a 2.5 star rating due to the large number of one-star reviews. At this point, there are more one-star reviews than five-star ones. A Lexus owner said the tire was punctured at 3,900 miles. Someone with a Mercedes-Benz GLC 300 4-Matic had their rear tire blow out at 7,500 miles. Another added, “These are the worst tires I have ever owned. They have only 18,000 miles and are already half worn.” 

On top of losing tread quite quickly, many drivers feel that Michelin’s Primacy All-Season tires are not meant for all seasons. One customer driving a Volvo EX30 said that the performance in icy and snowy conditions was “dangerously poor”. Another customer questioned how they can be all-season tires if they don’t work well in the rain or snow.

The lifespan of your tires will depend on a lot of factors, but a (very extensive) test by Consumer Reports found that all-season tires can last 55,000 to 95,000 miles. This was the result after testing 44 tires over 352,000 miles, driving in 500-mile shifts at a time. Results can vary as you may be driving on different road conditions in a different kind of car. It’s safe to say, however, that the Michelin Primacy All-Season tires used by the one-star reviewers are not lasting anywhere near long enough. 

You can extend your tires’ lifespan by checking your tire pressure every 3,000 miles, rotating your tires every 6,000 to 8,000 miles, getting your alignment checked periodically (or when your vehicle starts pulling to one side), and checking the tires’ treadwear. Also, you should avoid using the wrong tires for the season or for your vehicle. If you’re looking for an alternative to Michelin Primacy All-Season tires, try the CrossClimate2 — a favorite Michelin tire.