Who’ll Own Your Inevitable AI Assistant? The Battle Is On, and I Predict One Winner


Welcome to CNET’s new series of guest columns called Alt View, a forum for a diverse array of experts and luminaries to share their insights into the rapidly evolving field of artificial intelligence. For more AI coverage, check out CNET’s AI Atlas.


Every great technology gives humans a new superpower. The personal computer put the power of computing into the hands of individuals, turning machines once reserved for governments, universities and corporations into tools anyone could use. The internet gave us access to the world’s information. The smartphone put that power in our pockets, connecting us to anyone and anything from almost anywhere.

Each breakthrough changed what one person could do. But even with all this technology, we’re still the ones doing a lot of the work. We schedule meetings, organize our inboxes, manage dozens of apps, absorb endless amounts of information and make thousands of small decisions every day.

In platform shifts, tech feels like a tool before it becomes something bigger. AI is in that moment now. We mostly experience AI as something we ask questions of or give tasks to. But the breakthrough comes when AI understands, not just responds. 

A glowing translucent lightbulb, held by a hand, in front of lighted lines suggesting a circuit board

I’ve spent my career experiencing and even causing platform shifts. The Mac. The iPod. The iPhone. Nest. Every one of these transitions had something in common: taking a capability that used to be rare, difficult or expensive and making it more accessible. The builders who understood the behavioral shift, not just the technology shift, were the ones who built something that lasted.

AI assistants are the next big shift.

A handful of people have had another kind of superpower: a great assistant. It’s a superpower not because someone answers their emails or books their flights – those are helpful tasks. The real value of an assistant is that they understand the person behind the tasks: who you are, your relationships, your routines, your family, what you prioritize and what keeps you up at night. They know what to handle, what to bundle together and what truly needs your attention. 

A great assistant can anticipate what you need before you even ask. But that relationship doesn’t happen overnight. It takes years of working together, learning patterns, building trust and accumulating context.

Once you have that superpower, you never want to lose it. Losing a great assistant means losing years of shared knowledge and understanding. That accumulated understanding is what transforms an assistant from someone who helps you complete tasks into someone who expands what you can do. 

Most people have never had an assistant or seen how a great one actually works, which means we are learning two things at once: what an assistant can do and what AI can become. 

AI is beginning to act as a painkiller. It can remove friction, automate some tasks and help us move faster. But we still manage AI more than AI manages us. We prompt, correct and guide. That will change. 

A painkiller removes the pain you already feel. A superpower goes beyond removing pain. It unlocks new capabilities you couldn’t even have imagined. However, building an AI assistant that gives you these superpowers requires a lot more context than what we’ve got right now.

These are the moments in technology that matter. When a new capability forces us to rethink what’s possible and what we should expect from the products in our lives.

Building an AI assistant

A freelancer juggling three clients, six deadlines and a stack of unpaid invoices will soon have an AI assistant that keeps track of it all, so they can focus on the work instead of the overhead. A parent will use it to manage the family calendar, school reminders, grocery lists and doctor’s appointments. A student will have it organize coursework, prepare for exams and stay on top of deadlines. An aging adult will rely on it for medication reminders and appointment coordination.

An AI assistant isn’t a chatbot. It isn’t a single model or one agent completing a task. Those are pieces of the solution. A great AI assistant isn’t one thing. Like every great product, an AI assistant is the result of many technologies working together seamlessly to create one simple experience. Soon your AI assistant won’t just tell you your flight is delayed. It will understand why that delay matters, rebook it, notify the people you’re meeting and update your calendar.

Context gives the assistant awareness. The ability to know if you’re at work, at home, traveling, in a meeting, exercising or spending time with family. The richer the context, the more useful and personalized your assistant becomes. 

Memory allows the assistant to learnyour preferences, workflows, habits, relationships, routines and prior conversations over time.

The right interaction and personality build trust. Every assistant develops a communication style, tone and patterns that feel natural to the person using it.

Skills give assistants the ability to get things done: research, coding, scheduling, financial analysis, design tools, travel coordination, health tracking or interacting with other specialized agents.

And finally, reflection, the ability for an assistant to synthesize information across your workflows, interests, relationships and routines to identify patterns and surface useful insights you wouldn’t have found on your own.

Together they’re what turn AI from a tool that responds into an AI assistant that understands you.

The AI assistant adoption curve

Most people still don’t know they need an AI assistant. That’s not unusual for a new platform. In the early days of personal computing, most people didn’t understand why they’d ever need a Mac or a PC. Computers felt niche, technical, and disconnected from real life. Apple understood that behaviors had to change before the platform could scale, so it got Macs into classrooms, invested in student pricing and made the product familiar before it was necessary. If you learned on Apple, Apple became second nature and trusted.

ChatGPT reached 100 million users faster than any consumer technology in internet history. People are already living with AI, but we’re still in the early stages. The next shift moves this tool from occasional chatbot to a trusted assistant working persistently by your side.

The first experiences didn’t feel like AI at all. They felt like smarter search. Now, we’re having it do simple things automatically: sports scores, weather alerts and travel itineraries. Next, the delegation increases. That’s the important shift.

The more useful an assistant becomes, the more you rely on it. The more you rely on it, the more memory accumulates and trust builds. Eventually it weaves itself into your life, helps you manage life and even enjoy life. 

The iPhone had a similar path. It started as a phone that you could use to check email. Then it became your wallet, your navigation system, your camera, your music player, your messaging platform and eventually something most people cannot leave home without. We’re still in the email-checking phase of AI assistants. There’s a lot more to unlock.

The battle for the AI assistant

Platform wars have been fought over apps, ecosystems, operating systems, developer relationships and network effects. This one is different.

The model is not the assistant. The assistant is the platform.

We’ve seen this pattern before. The iPhone brought together hardware, software, services and an ecosystem that changed how people interacted with tech. The same will be true for AI. 

Tony Fadell with an original iPod and a Nest thermostat

Tony Fadell helped create the iPod before going on to found Nest.

Tony Fadell/CNET

The AI platform war won’t be won by the model alone. Whoever builds the complete assistant experience with context, memory, interaction, skills and reflection all working together will win this war. 

You tell your AI assistant you need to go to New York for a meeting Wednesday and be home by Friday evening, for example. Without context it doesn’t know where to book the flight from. Without memory it doesn’t know you always choose an aisle seat, prefer the same Midtown hotel and need to be back home for school pickup. 

Context tells the model what’s happening right now. Memory tells it who you are. Skills allow it to act. The interaction builds trust. Reflection helps it connect patterns and anticipate what you need next. The model is the brain that processes information and generates responses. But a brain alone isn’t enough. Without the rest of the system, every interaction starts from zero.

Microsoft, Google, Apple, Anthropic, OpenAI, Perplexity and xAI are all competing to own this very personal interaction with you. Right now, for most of them, the model is their moat. But models are already commoditizing. Our personal hardware devices will plug into different AI “brains” – in the cloud or on devices themselves – whichever are cheapest, fastest or offer up more privacy.

The real moat will be the complete assistant built around you over time.

No single cloud service can see the full picture of your life. But a connected ecosystem of devices can. Your phone knows your location, your watch knows your heart rate, your laptop knows your calendar, your glasses know who you’re talking to. Each signal is useful alone. Combined, they create a much more powerful portrait the assistant can use to understand you.

This is what I call the Federation of Devices. Whoever controls this Federation of Devices has the foundation to build the most trusted and most valuable AI assistant.

The cloud doesn’t scale

A real AI assistant isn’t something you ask just a couple questions a day. It’s always helping. And that requires constant compute. If every interaction must travel to the cloud, the cost of running a truly personal AI assistant starts looking a lot more like paying for a human assistant, which is out of reach for most consumers.

The only way this scales is to move more intelligence closer to you.

Think about your home security camera. You don’t want every frame of video sent to a remote server just to detect motion. Processing happens on the device because the economics, speed and privacy demand it. Smart glasses that translate a conversation in real time can’t wait for a round trip to a data center. You’d be halfway through the sentence before the answer came back. 

AI Atlas

Your AI assistant is no different. Local AI handles the routine. Cloud models handle the complex reasoning. Companies like Plumerai are building exactly for this moment with tiny AI models small enough to run on a chip the size of a thumbnail and powerful enough to handle the tasks you need most. (Editors’ note: Tony Fadell is an investor in Plumerai.)

The future won’t be everything in the cloud or everything on device. The architecture will be distributed. That’s how you get the economics to work.

The cloud doesn’t know you’re cold

The company that controls the federation of devices wins. With 2.5 billion active devices, that’s Apple’s hand.

Google has incredible server-side infrastructure: Gemini, custom TPUs, data centers, Search, Gmail, Maps, Android and YouTube. Nobody is closer to owning the model and cloud layer. But the cloud doesn’t know you’re cold. It doesn’t know that you’re driving, your meeting just ended or who you’re talking to. Your devices do.

Apple has the iPhone, Mac, Apple Watch, AirPods, the identity layer, edge computing and one of the deepest consumer trust relationships in the history of technology. M-series chips power your Mac and iPad. A-series chips power your iPhone and Apple Watch. Both share the same unified architecture, CPU, GPU and memory on a single chip, built for AI at the edge. Apple’s Federation of Devices will run AI on device and coordinate with more powerful models in the cloud when needed. The Apple and Gemini partnership is a signal of where this is going.

The model matters less than who controls the assistant built around you, that’s the lasting advantage. You can swap the brain. You can’t swap the memory, context and trust built over time.

Questions nobody has answered yet

We’re building this plane while flying it. I’ve spent 30-plus years building products that changed how people live. I didn’t always anticipate the questions they’d raise. This time I’m asking them.

If your AI assistant understands your communication style, workflows, negotiation patterns and institutional knowledge, who owns that context when you leave a company? If it becomes deeply integrated into healthcare, what happens when providers or insurance systems change? How portable should memory and personalization be across systems?

And then there’s the question nobody in the industry wants to ask. An assistant that knows you better than most people, is always available, is endlessly patient, is never judgmental… that’s a very powerful tool. Possibly too powerful and addictive in ways we haven’t fully reckoned with. 

We built the iPhone without asking what it would do to human connection. We should ask that question now with AI.

When we chose the iPhone over an Android device, or a Mac over a PC, we were choosing a phone or a computer. This time we’re choosing something that will know how we think, work and live. That’s never happened before. Humans are at the center of this platform shift. Build it like it matters.





Source link

Leave a Reply

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get our latest articles delivered straight to your inbox. No spam, we promise.

Recent Reviews


Alaska doesn’t reward rushing. It rewards curiosity, patience, and a willingness to follow the wild where it leads. That’s why an Alaska UnCruise feels less like a vacation and more like an immersion. These small-ship journeys trade crowds and fixed itineraries for quiet coves, misty fjords, and days shaped by tides, weather, and wildlife instead of a clock.

We recently sailed with UnCruise from Juneau on one of their most iconic itineraries, and we can’t wait to share our firsthand experience. One morning we were kayaking beneath hanging glaciers; the next we were bushwhacking through old-growth forest or skiffing toward a shoreline that rarely sees footprints. With Uncruise we discovered Alaska at human scale: intimate, flexible, and deeply connected to the place itself.

Read on to see whether an Alaska UnCruise belongs on your bucket list.

Wild, Woolly, and Wow: The Glacier Bay Loop

LeConte Bay Alaska
Photo Credit: Jenn Coleman.

UnCruise operates trips in four of Alaska’s five regions, Southeast, Southcentral, Interior, and Southwest, but Juneau is the heart of the operation. It’s their most popular port, offering round-trip voyages through the Inside Passage as well as one-way itineraries connecting to Sitka, Ketchikan, Seattle, and Seward.

We sailed the Wild, Woolly, and Wow with Glacier Bay itinerary: a week-long, round-trip voyage from Juneau that includes one full day in Glacier Bay. Some sailings offer two days in the park, but for us, one was plenty. We woke at the base of a tidewater glacier deep in the bay and sailed out at sunset—hard to imagine a better bookend.

What really surprised us was how much we enjoyed the glaciers outside Glacier Bay. Many UnCruise itineraries explore additional tidewater glaciers that mega-ships can’t access. These areas came with fewer people, more time ashore, fewer restrictions, and, often, better weather. Glacier Bay’s massive icefields can generate their own conditions, which means sunshine elsewhere while the park sits under clouds.

Because UnCruise captains have the freedom to choose anchorages based on real-time conditions, no two trips are identical. Still, the geography naturally creates a rhythm: a loose loop around Admiralty Island, Glacier Bay to the northwest, quieter glacier systems to the southeast, and countless bays and backwaters in between for kayaking, bushwhacking, and skiff exploration.

UnCruising vs. Traditional Cruising

Kayaks on UnCruise Waterfall Cove Alaska
Photo Credit: Jenn Coleman.

Traditional cruising runs on a dual-revenue model. Competitive ticket prices, often low-margin or even loss leaders, are offset by onboard spending like drinks, specialty dining, spa treatments, internet, and retail. Scale is the strategy: 3,000 to 6,000+ passengers spread operational costs thin.

UnCruise flips that model on its head. With all-inclusive pricing and fewer than 90 passengers, the experience feels more like an adult summer camp than a floating resort. Instead of pulling into ports for pre-packaged shore excursions, the ships anchor in remote bays and rely on an in-house guide team. You’re not herded; you’re invited.

The payoff is connection, both to the place and the people. With such a small guest count, you quickly learn names, swap stories, and share the day’s highlights over genuinely excellent food and drinks that reflect the region you’re sailing through.

Alaska UnCruise vs. Other UnCruises

Kayaking Glacier Bay Alaska
Photo Credit: Jenn Coleman.

This was our third UnCruise, following trips to the Sea of Cortez and Hawaii. Alaska felt different, a good way. UnCruise started here, and it shows. The Alaska program leans heavily into wilderness exploration led by the onboard team, rather than outsourced excursions.

In Hawaii and Mexico, proximity to towns meant more third-party activities, bike rides, cultural tours, and the like. Alaska, by contrast, felt raw and remote, with days shaped almost entirely by weather, wildlife, and opportunity.

It was also colder. Hawaii and Mexico invited snorkeling and free swimming; Alaska required more gear, better tides, and a stronger sense of humor to enter the water. We did the polar plunge more for the bragging rights than the pleasure, and we’d do it again.

Life Aboard the Wilderness Legacy

Sam is delivering an after-dinner program
Photo Credit: Jenn Coleman.

The Wilderness Legacy is UnCruise’s largest ship, carrying up to 90 guests. Interestingly, similar Glacier Bay itineraries are also offered on much smaller vessels, down to just 22 passengers, depending on how intimate you want the experience to be.

We appreciated the comforts onboard: reliable Wi-Fi and hot tubs, which make glacier watching from bubbling water feel downright legendary. Cabins were compact but comfortable, no Instagram-perfect balconies here, but if your goal is to spend the day outdoors, that’s a fair trade.

Two spacious common areas brought everyone together for meals, happy hour, and nightly programming. From naturalist talks to talent shows and the always-anticipated end-of-voyage slideshow, every evening felt communal and relaxed.

The Real Reason You UnCruise: Activities

Skiff Tour LeConte Bay Alaska
Photo Credit: Jenn Coleman.

You don’t UnCruise to stay onboard. You UnCruise to get out into it.

Most days offered three core options, bushwhacking, kayaking, and skiff tours, both morning and afternoon. Plans shifted with weather and conditions, which is part of the magic. Southeast Alaska is a temperate rainforest, after all.

Our loose strategy: kayak on clear days, bushwhack in the rain, and choose skiff tours when there was something extraordinary to see, like bears feeding at Pavlov Creek. It wasn’t scientific, but it worked.

Some moments were non-negotiable: skiffing up to tidewater glaciers, the mandatory kayak orientation, or simply staying aboard when wildlife appeared unexpectedly, like the pod of roughly 30 orcas that surfaced as we exited Glacier Bay.

One of the biggest advantages of small-ship cruising is how well the guides get to know you. By midweek, excursions were subtly tailored to guests’ interests and abilities, making everyone feel both supported and challenged.

Food Worth Planning Your Day Around

UnCruise Crab Leg dinner
Photo Credit: Jenn Coleman.

Forget buffet lines. Every meal onboard was cooked to order, with meat, seafood, and vegetarian options. Everything was so good that ordering a “partial of all three” became a habit. Ordering ahead also helped reduce food waste, which we appreciated.

Dietary restrictions were handled seamlessly, and the menus reflected a strong sense of place like crab boils, butter-poached halibut, and other Alaska-forward dishes. Morning meal announcements became a highlight, and we learned to choose our breakfast seat strategically so we’d have time to contemplate dinner choices before they took our order.

An onboard pastry chef kept desserts dialed in, while talented bartenders handled everything from classics to the cocktail of the day. Happy hour quickly became a ritual: swapping stories, snacking on charcuterie and baked brie, and trying not to ruin our appetite for dinner.

Cabins: Functional, Thoughtful, and Surprisingly Cozy

Cabin-Navigator Cabin UnCruise Wilderness Legacy
Photo Credit: UnCruise Adventures.

Cabins aren’t luxurious, but they are smartly designed. Full bathrooms, potable tap water, comfortable beds, and enough storage, assuming you don’t overpack.

Our favorite feature? Hooks. Lots of them. Perfect for drying wet gear after a day outside. By the end of the voyage, the hallways looked like an REI sidewalk sale caught in a rainstorm, but our cabin always felt clean, dry, and warm.

It’s also worth noting how skilled our captain was at selecting sheltered anchorages. Even when a strong storm rolled through, we slept soundly each night, tucked behind towering cliffs that blocked the wind. Every morning delivered a new view, complete with freshly fed waterfalls spilling down the rock walls.

What to Pack (and What Not To)

Neka Bay Alaska
Photo Credit: Jenn Coleman.

UnCruise provides excellent packing lists, but the guiding principles are simple: dress in layers and expect to get wet. Waterproof pants and a solid rain jacket are non-negotiable.

Footwear is more forgiving. You’re issued gum boots, the unofficial uniform of Alaska, and we wore them every time we left the ship, including for kayaking.

One pro tip: bring soft luggage. We packed everything into soft-sided bags that folded away easily during the voyage. It kept us from overpacking and made cabin life much simpler.

Bonus Time in Juneau

Tahku whale sculpture Juneau Alaska
Photo Credit: Jenn Coleman.

As immersive as the UnCruise experience is, we would’ve felt shortchanged if we hadn’t added time in Juneau for classic Alaska adventures.

The good news: Juneau makes it easy. Seaplane tours depart right from the dock, and Mendenhall Glacier is just 20 miles away. Depending on your budget and appetite for adventure, you can reach it by bus, helicopter, or something in between and choose from ice climbing, paddling, dog sledding, or a simple walkabout.

And since you missed-out on onboard shopping during the cruise, Juneau Harbor has you covered.

The Takeaway: Who Alaska UnCruise Is (and Isn’t) For

2 bears with a salmon Pavlovs Bay Alaska
Photo Credit: Jenn Coleman.

An Alaska UnCruise isn’t about checking boxes or lounging poolside. It’s about slowing down, leaning into uncertainty, and letting the landscape set the agenda. You trade predictability for possibility, and that’s exactly the point.

If you’re curious, flexible, and happiest when your days are shaped by weather reports and wildlife sightings instead of reservations and alarms, this style of travel will feel like coming home. Alaska is vast and wild, but UnCruise has a way of making it feel personal.

For us, it wasn’t just a trip, it was a reminder of how powerful travel can be when you let a place lead.

Disclosure: A big thank you to Uncruise Adventures for hosting us! For more Uncruise travel inspiration, check out their InstagramFacebook, and YouTube accounts.

As always, the views and opinions expressed are entirely our own, and we only recommend brands and destinations that we 100% stand behind.

Ready to Book Your Trip? These Links Will Make It Easy:

Airfare:

Insurance:

  • Protect your trip and yourself with Squaremouth and Medjet
  • Safeguard your digital information by using a VPN. We love NordVPN as it is superfast for streaming Netflix
  • Stay safe on the go and stay connected with an eSim card through AloSIM

Our Packing Favs:

  • We LOVE Matador Equipment for their innovative products and sustainability focus. Their SEG45 is a game changer when you need large capacity while packing light.
  • Travel in style with a suitcase, carry-on, backpack, or handbag from Knack Bags
  • Packing cubes make organized packing a breeze! We love these from Eagle Creek

Like it? Pin it for later on Pinterest!

Hi! We are Jenn and Ed Coleman aka Coleman Concierge. In a nutshell, we are a Huntsville-based Gen X couple sharing our stories of amazing adventures through activity-driven transformational and experiential travel.





Source link